As the
final days of April approach, the much-publicized
issue over the sale of one of the nation's
longest-running Boy Scout camps, Camp Glen Gray, is
expected to come to a close. The tract, located in the
Ramapo Mountains and dedicated in 1917 by Scouting
troops mostly from Montclair, is expected to be sold
by the Northern New Jersey Council of the Boy Scouts
of America for at least $4 million.
Based in Montclair, a grassroots organization,
Friends of Glen Gray, is raising money to purchase at
least 200 of the more than 800 acres in a cooperative
deal with The Trust for Public Land, which plans to
turn the rest of the tract over to Bergen County for
open space. Friends of Glen Gray hopes to keep its
area as a camp, not only for the Boy Scouts, but for
other parties such as Girl Scouts and school groups.
"We're trying to support a resolution that has
a long-term solution for the camp," said John
Hartinger, spokesperson for Friends of Glen Gray. If
the group obtains the camp, then it will be maintained
by an endowment fund and from usage fees.
There have been competing offers for the camp,
according to Jon Brennan, assistant executive for the
Northern New Jersey Council, most of which would also
preserve the land as open space but would pay more
than $4 million. Some de-velopers have made
unsolicited offers, said Brennan, but the council has
made it clear it wants to sell the tract for open
space. The Trust for Public land is negotiating under
an April deadline, he said, which is why there are
some who feel the talks may soon conclude.
Three Montclair Scout troops have cabins at Glen
Gray, which they use frequently. For those troops, the
camp was established as a place of permanency, a
stretch of the great outdoors to be used when they
wanted and how they wanted.
But Brennan explained that, in the perception of
the Northern New Jersey Council, the tract is now
redundant.
Camp Glen Gray was acquired when the Essex Council
merged with those from Bergen, Passaic and Hudson
counties to form the Northern New Jersey Council in
1998. The new council wound up with more than 10
camps. Brennan said the council could run its camp
program for troop members with only half that number.
Camp Glen Gray is one of five camps owned fully by the
council, and since it isn't as handicapped-accessible
as others, the council voted in January 2001 to sell
it.
Brennan denied that the camp is being sold to help
cover the costs of the council's new $3.8 million
headquarters in Oakland, or to compensate for funding
from the United Way that has been withdrawn from the
council because of the national council's decision to
ban gay Scout leaders. The latter point is definitely
a concern though, Brennan acknowledged.
"I hope they're feeling some pressure,"
said Ken Cowing, co-Scoutmaster of Montclair's Cub
Scout Pack 5. "Increasingly, I've heard a lot of
parents say they're unwilling to donate, which forces
us to just take care of our own local pack.
"The executives that are basically in power
are apparently from the other coun-cil, so they don't
have that attachment to history," said Cowing, of
the sale of Camp Glen Gray. "What we're talking
about is something related to the history and soul of
our area. Camp Glen Gray was founded by people from
our area."
That may be so, but Brennan said that there were
members on the Northern New Jersey Council from Essex
County who voted to sell the tract.
The camp's history is rooted in Montclair, entwined
with the legacy of the man whose name the tract
carries, Frank Fellows Gray.
Gray, called Uncle by many Scouts of his time, was
a poet, a teacher, an enigma. He dedicated his life to
the development of Scouting as some men dedicate their
lives to evangelism, or missionary work, as though the
act of offering direction to others was the only thing
that filled his own desire for meaning.
Gray has been described as a man who was not very
open about his history or personal life. As he forged
a legacy in the early part of this century as one of
the first American men to create a Boy Scout troop,
Gray carried an air of mystery that left those who
knew him best recounting their time together with an
almost mythical tone, like some great campfire story.
As Luther Edmunds Price recounted in his book,
"Thirty Years of Scout Camping," compiled in
1940, "Mr. Gray left too little in the way of
memoirs. A research extending over many years has
failed to disclose any record which will give a
complete picture of Mr. Gray's life. Even as regards
his age there was a mystery, an insoluble
mystery."
As headmaster of a New York military academy, Gray
suffered a personal tragedy, retired, and took up a
short residence in the home of a Long Island clergyman
and friend, Rev. Wilbur Schoonhoven, to recover.
"He never spoke freely of his parents,"
Schoonhoven stated of Gray in Price's book. "His
father was unsympathetic with his boyhood aims, but
his mother he adored. He always impressed me as having
a great sorrow hidden away in his heart...He would
ridicule the foibles of his pupils, but they would
take it, realizing the great hearted, sympathetic
manliness of his nature and admiring his sterling
qualities of character."
Soon after, Gray moved to Montclair, and as Price
stated, "established himself as an expert in the
training of difficult boys in the public school
system."
In 1907, Gray traveled to Great Britain and
returned the follow-ing year, having studied a
developing method of Scouting for boys based on the
wartime survival manuals of Robert Baden-Powell, the
future father of Boy Scouts.
By 1909, Gray had formed his own group of boys from
Montclair that he and other counselors would take
hiking and camping trips. Price hinted in his book
that it may have been the first troop in the United
States trained in the Baden-Powell method but later
acknowledged that even Gray admitted he didn't know
for sure.
However, the troop, later to be known as Troop 4,
received a visit from Baden-Powell himself in 1912,
and the leader bestowed his own name exclusively on
the group. The following year, Gray was made
commissioner of the Montclair Scout Coun-cil.
Price stated that the period between 1910 and 1917
was the "nomadic" period for Scouts in the
Montclair area. Gray's group camped at several places
during that time frame, including Dudley Island on
Lake Wawayanda and at Forge Pond on the Wanaque River.
Gray took several Scouts to tour Great Britain and
Ireland in 1912 and to Bermuda in 1913. Scouts were
also taken on educational trips to historic
battlefields such as Bunker Hill and Gettysburg.
But it soon became apparent that the Scouts needed
a camp space to call their own, a place they could be
sure would always be available. The council formed a
search committee in 1916, and after narrowing down
five choice spots, decided that an area in the Ramapo
Mountains, just 20 miles from Montclair, would be
best.
The tract was ideal for the adventurous young
person, with American Indian trails that still held
the promise of finding Native American relics, and a
history steeped in the American Revolution.
The council bought the 820-acre tract piece by
piece, and Camp Glen Gray, named for Frank Fellows
Gray, was dedicated in 1917.
"I was very involved (with the camp),"
said John McMullen, Montclair resident and former
owner of the New Jersey Devils. McMullen was named to
a coveted position of The Old Guard, a select group of
Scouts whose charge it is to protect and maintain Camp
Glen Gray.
Some of McMullen's favorite memories are of working
together with his father, a strong supporter of the
Scouts, at the camp on such projects as building a
cabin.
"Quite a number of fathers went to Glen
Gray," said Cowing. They'd send their sons to the
camp, who would in turn send their sons.
"It has a tremendous history, and has been
used by generations of Scouts," said Hartinger.
"When Scouts go out and sit by that campfire,
they're participating in that tradition."
"My dad was one of the founders of Camp Glen
Gray," said Irving Porter, who grew up in
Montclair but now lives in Maine. "He used to
help 'Uncle' out before I was old enough to be a
Scout."
Irving Porter said his father, Henry Porter, met
Gray at the YMCA shortly after moving to Montclair in
1911. The two became friends, Irving said, and the
elder Porter started accompanying Gray to the
Montclair schools to encourage boys to become Scouts.
"My dad would roll over in his grave if he
knew that [Glen Gray was being sold]," said
Irving.
McMullen agreed, saying he didn't really like the
idea of the camp being sold, though he admitted he
didn't know the details enough to comment further.
McMullen has, however, given his support to Friends of
Glen Gray, as have many Scout alumni, according to
Hartinger.
"A number of people who know each other from
Scouts and who used camp Glen Gray got together to
come up with ideas of what we could do," said
Hartinger.
Many have donated money to Friends of Glen Gray,
while others are volunteering their time spreading the
word of the organization's efforts to buy the land.
Anyone interested in contributing time or money to the
campaign can visit www.glengray.org on the Internet.
In the meantime, Hartinger is approaching another
session of negotiations with the Northern New Jersey
Council's subcommittee, which will soon release its
recommendation to the council. Because of the
sensitivity of the talks, Hartinger was cautious about
saying how much money has been raised, or whether he
even thought Friends of Glen Gray had a chance of
securing the land from the council.
For Cowing, the notion that there will now be newer
camps with better facilities for his Cub Scouts rather
than the rugged outdoor slopes of Camp Glen Gray seems
like a weak trade-off.
Cowing said that the quarter-mile hike from the
Glen Gray parking lot to the camping facilities is
part of what an outdoor weekend is supposed to be
about.
"It's like saying we can make plenty of
reproductions of the Liberty Bell, so we don't need
this one," said Cowing.